So more on the SOA protest. For those of you who are unfamiliar with the School of the Americas, a quick background. The School of the Americas is a training facility for Latin American armies, militias and police. It's well documented that those trained by the SOA have enacted all sorts of human rights violations upon their own people. Most of those killed were "counter-insurgents," those working against oppressive regimes in their countries. One of the most famous was Fr. Oscar Romero who was murdered by soliders in El Salvador while saying Mass. In 1989 nine Jesuit priests, their housekeeper and her daughter were murdered. Graduates from the SOA have been connected to paramilitary organizations, drug cartels, guerilla militias and torture camps. They learned it all at Ft Benning.
In 2001 the U.N. did an investigation into SOA and discovered training manuals teaching students torture and assassination. The school claims to be training for the spread of democracy which I believe is true. The problem is that this is democracy at any price. The school was shut down and reopened some six months later under the name Western Hemisphere's Institute for Security Cooperation, WHINSEC. Supposedly the training changed. Yet SOA grads continue to end up in the news doing the same old thing.
The protest/vigil occurs once a year on the anniversary of the nine murdered priests. It is staunchly non-violent and deeply rooted in the social justice tradition of the Catholic church (the vigil was first organized by a Maryknoll priest). The main event happens on Sunday when a group of 25,000 (SOA Watch estimate, Ft Benning said only 11,000) show up at the gates and walk in a slow circle as the names of each person killed by someone who graduated from the SOA is sung. Everyone has a white cross and holds it up after each name saying, "presente." It's an act of solidarity, saying "although the world stood by while you died, we will never let this happen again."
SOA/WHINSEC weekend also ends up being something like a family reunion for folks like me. I saw people I knew from Jubilee Partners, Koinonia, Open Door, LA Catholic Worker, the Jesuit Volunteers and Sojourners. There were friends, friends who knew friends and those who will be our friends next year. It's a huge celebration of the great work being done in so many different ways around the country and the world.
Technically the goal of the protest is to shut down the school. Interestingly, Amnesty International doesn't promote this as a solution. Their opinion is that even if the school closed down, it would just open again somewhere else. I think they're right. The real solution (one which SOA Watch works on quite actively) is to get Latin American countries to stop sending their militaries to SOA/WHINSEC. So far I think six countries have agreed.
This was my first time at the vigil and I was with seven seniors from University of Portland. Last year we only sent two students and before that I believe we went through several years without sending any students. Students at my university are highly resistant to the idea of protest. One guess as to why is the obsession with effectiveness. If it doesn't seem like it will make an immediate change through an acceptable channel (legal, safe, fast, affirmed) then we shouldn't be doing it. I think the large ROTC presence on campus also makes it difficult to allow conflict on this issue to exist. It's better (read easier) to just ignore it and try to get along. Because of this, I think the vigil is one of the most effective training tools for civic engagement. Someone described it to me as a "protest fair." While I don't love bumper sticker social justice (how about just living faithfully?) it's great for my students to see that there are all sorts of movements happening and so many young people involved.
I know one of the difficult parts for them was all the rhetoric around "making change." I couldn't agree more. Always at things like this there's a lot of talk about a better world, the end of conflict and war. That's why a visit to
Koinonia Partner Farms is always so wonderful. After the vigil ended we drove an hour out visit the community in Americus, GA. I went there with my students over the summer when I was leading our Civil Rights program. It's one of my favorite places. I always appreciate experiencing the dailyness of their struggle to live racial and economic equality in the deep South. Protests are important but these are short term signs of change. People go home, forget. Lives don't necessarily change. The people at Koinonia live the message out every day and they extend their reach in amazing ways.
The breadth of Koinonia's witness especially hit home talking to one of the older guys. He was referencing one part of the vigil (No Mas! No More!) and telling us how that originated there on the farm. But at the time they weren't talking about SOA but the Civil Rights struggle. Then it was Vietnam. Then it was nuclear proliferation. Then it was the Cold War. Struggles for justice are not going to be over until the Lord returns. If the SOA shuts down, there will be something else to take it's place, some other way the poor are brought low. There always has been. But I also know that the church (and those outside the church who teach us to be the church) will always be ready to say "presente" for the alien, the orphan and the widow who are shot down, starved, tortured or disappeared. That's the kingdom of God.
I'll load up some pictures when I come back from Iowa.